Alaska: Peltola leads by 3,975 votes, but loses in court and it all comes down to November 18
A judge called the Democratic campaign's request for the list of rejected absentee ballots "not reasonable." It is the only Senate race still without a winner, and the votes of two minor candidates exceed the margin.

Alaska Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews on Wednesday, November 11, rejected a lawsuit by Democrat Mary Peltola's campaign seeking from election officials the list of rejected absentee ballots and the reason for each rejection. According to The Associated Press, the judge ruled a day after hearing arguments and found the request "not reasonable," especially given the time pressure officials face while still counting votes.
The state argued that releasing the information would violate voter privacy: in an affidavit, Michaela Thompson, who oversees the absentee ballot review boards, explained that the observers' version of the report includes home addresses and that observers sign confidentiality agreements. Campaign attorney Abha Khanna said they were not trying to slow the count and had seen no cause for alarm, and only wanted in centralized form information observers already see. Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan's campaign was allowed to intervene in the case.
Meanwhile, Peltola's lead holds. With about 86% of the expected vote counted (more than 248,000 ballots), Peltola had 121,487 votes (48.9%) to Sullivan's 117,512 (47.3%), a 3,975-vote gap, according to the official count cited on November 12 by AP and Reuters. Since no one tops 50%, the race will be settled by ranked-choice tabulation: Gerald Heikes has 5,426 votes and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a different candidate from the senator, has 4,100, so their voters' second choices exceed the current margin.
Alaska accepts overseas ballots up to 15 days after the election, so November 18 is the last day to receive them and also the date the Division of Elections plans to run the ranked-choice tabulation; certification is expected on November 25. It is the only Senate race AP has not yet called: if Peltola wins, Democrats, who already have 55 seats after Scott Colom's victory in Mississippi, would reach 56. On the same ballot, the measure to repeal Alaska's ranked-choice voting was failing 52.5% to 47.5%.
In ranked-choice elections, a first-round lead is not enough: campaigns must court the second choices of minor candidates' voters from the start. And in a tight count, litigation should ask for what a judge will find reasonable under counting deadlines; a lawsuit that looks like an obstacle costs in the narrative even if it changes no votes.
Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.
FOCUS courtesy space


