Issue No. 01 · November 2026
The magazine of political consulting and marketing
United States · Messaging

Maine: the moderate brand no longer saved Susan Collins

Troy Jackson beat her by about five points after 30 years in the Senate. In 2020 Collins won despite trailing in every poll; this time the surveys got it right: 49-45 and 49-47 in the final weeks.

Maine: the moderate brand no longer saved Susan Collins
Illustrative AI-generated image. It does not depict real people or events.

Susan Collins, the only Republican senator from a state Trump lost in 2024, fell to Democrat Troy Jackson. When CNN called the race just after 12:15 a.m. ET, Jackson led Collins by about five points with 68% of the vote counted, according to Newsweek. Collins had held the seat for 30 years, per The Boston Globe.

The craft lesson is in the comparison with 2020. That year Collins won reelection with more than 50% despite trailing Democrat Sara Gideon in public polls, and ever since, 'the polls underestimate Collins' became a rule analysts applied almost automatically. In 2026 the rule failed: the final measurements pointed the right way.

The numbers: CNN/SSRS, October 20-26 with 783 likely voters, had Jackson 49% and Collins 45%. Marist, October 22-25, measured 49% to 47%. Suffolk, October 8-11 with 500 voters and a ±4.4-point margin of error, also had 49% to 47%. Three different shops, the same narrow range and the same winner.

On money the story was mixed: Jackson outraised Collins four to one in the most recent quarter, but she led in overall fundraising and outside support, according to Newsweek. Collins's stance on the Iran war — she argued that passing the resolution 'would send the wrong message to Iran and to our troops' — was one of the points Democrats used to erode her independent profile.

Lesson for consultants

Correcting data 'from memory' is the costliest mistake in the trade. If three independent pollsters converge on a range, the reasonable adjustment is zero: a bias observed in one cycle is not a constant of the candidate. And a 30-year moderate brand runs out when voters decide by party, not by person.

Source: Newsweek · Nov 4, 2026Read the original story ↗

Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.

FOCUS · PDF edition

The print edition, in your inbox

Download the full magazine as a PDF (letter size) and get The Lens every Monday: five takeaways for people who run campaigns.

FOCUS No. 01