Issue No. 01 · November 2026
The magazine of political consulting and marketing
United States · Data

Hialeah went from −59 to −31: the 22-point Hispanic swing that was not enough in Florida

A precinct-by-precinct Axios analysis published on November 17 measures what happened to Florida's Hispanic vote on November 3: in Hispanic-majority precincts the Democratic Senate nominee, Angie Nixon, improved on Val Demings's 2022 margin by 22 points and still lost them by 2.8 points. The breakdown by origin is the real story: mostly Cuban precincts moved from R+34 to R+14, Puerto Rican ones from D+16 to D+35, and Mexican and Central American ones from D+3 to D+44. In Hialeah the Democratic deficit shrank from 59 points in 2022 to 31. Florida still stayed Republican.

Hialeah went from −59 to −31: the 22-point Hispanic swing that was not enough in Florida
Photo: Pixexid / Good Free Photos (CC0, public domain), panorama of Miami, Florida. Crop: FOCUS.

The figure that breaks the average is the breakdown by national origin. Axios sorted precincts by where most of their voters come from and found three different elections inside the single label "Hispanic": where the Cuban vote dominates, the Republican margin collapsed from 34 points to 14; where the Puerto Rican vote dominates, the Democratic edge grew from 16 to 35; and in Mexican and Central American precincts it went from 3 to 44 points. That is a 41-point gap between two groups that national polls usually put in the same cell of the table.

In Miami-Dade the movement is visible street by street. Nixon lost Hialeah by 31 points, where Demings had lost it by 59 in 2022 and Debbie Mucarsel-Powell by 53 in 2024; in Westchester the deficit fell from 55 points to 34, and in Tamiami from 54 to 33. There is a second number that explains part of that improvement and should not be mistaken for persuasion: in precincts where most voters were born in Cuba, 3% fewer ballots were cast than in 2022, while countywide ballots rose 7%. Democratic strategist Steve Schale put it plainly: the numbers do not show "the full picture" and cannot tell you whether Cuban voters changed their minds or simply stayed home.

The swing was broad and shallow. The five Democratic statewide nominees finished within 1.6 points of each other, a sign of bloc voting rather than personal pull: David Jolly improved on the 2022 governor's margin by more than 18 points -about 6 points above the median across the 36 states that voted- and Nixon improved on the Senate margin by nearly 14 points, barely a point above the national median. Jolly ran better than Nixon among white voters and in the most Jewish precincts of Miami-Dade, Palm Beach and Broward; Nixon ran about 3 points ahead of him among Black and Hispanic voters and about 4 points behind among white voters, by Axios's estimate.

Daniel Smith, a political scientist at the University of Florida, summed up the result in a line that belongs on the first page of any campaign memo: "There definitely was a broad blue shift, it just wasn't deep enough." To really compete in Florida, he added, Democrats need non-party affiliates and Republicans voting for them, not just recovered ground inside their own base. The only legislative seat that changed hands in the area was state House District 69, outside Tampa, won by Democrat Ashley Herrmann.

Lesson for consultants

The "Hispanic vote" category is useless for running a campaign, and Florida just produced the cleanest proof: a 41-point gap in movement between Cuban precincts and Mexican and Central American ones, in the same state, on the same day, on the same ballot. If you segment by language or surname, you are averaging three electorates that move in different directions at different speeds. The second lesson is less comfortable: before celebrating a margin improvement, split the margin into persuasion and turnout. In Hialeah the margin improved 28 points while 3% fewer ballots were cast than in 2022 and the county cast 7% more; much of that "gain" was an opponent who stayed home, not a voter who switched. The first cannot be banked for the next election. The second can.

Source: Axios Miami · Nov 19, 2026Read the original story ↗

Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.

FOCUS · PDF edition

The print edition, in your inbox

Download the full magazine as a PDF (letter size) and get The Lens every Monday: five takeaways for people who run campaigns.

FOCUS No. 01