Issue No. 01 · November 2026
The magazine of political consulting and marketing
United States · Data

35% of Trump's voters stayed home: turnout explains 10 of the 15-point swing

Pollster J.L. Partners published its post-mortem of the November 3 midterms on November 16: 35% of those who voted for Donald Trump in 2024 did not vote this year, against 22% of Kamala Harris's voters. Of the 15 points the national vote moved — from R+2 in 2024 to D+13 in 2026 — 10 come from Republican abstention and only 5 from voters who switched parties.

35% of Trump's voters stayed home: turnout explains 10 of the 15-point swing
Photo: Tony Webster / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0), a "Vote Here" sign outside a polling place in Minnesota. Cover design: FOCUS.

The report is called "Sitting Out the Surf" and is signed by J.L. Partners, a pollster that works in the United States and the United Kingdom. It was published on November 16, 2026 and combines an Election Day survey of 1,000 registered voters, fielded online with a nationally representative sample, with more than 30,000 interviews conducted during the campaign by SMS-to-web, online panel and live calls to landlines and cell phones. The margin of error is 3.1 points for all registered voters and 3.3 points for the subgroup of 870 people who had voted or were going to vote on November 3, weighted to the actual D+13 result in the House vote.

The central finding is electoral accounting. The national House vote went from R+2 in 2024 to D+13 in 2026: a 15-point swing. J.L. Partners attributes 10 of those points to turnout differences and 5 to voters who switched parties; that is, roughly two thirds of the Democratic gain was not built by convincing anyone, but by Republicans who did not show up. Some 35% of Trump's 2024 voters did not go to the polls, against 22% of Harris's. The abstention concentrated precisely in the electorate Trump had added: 46% among his voters without a college degree, 44% among those over 65 and 39% among rural voters. Just 8% of his 2024 voters — a little under one in ten — voted this time for Democratic candidates.

The survey also measures how solid the vote Democrats won really is, and the answer is: less than it looks. Some 48% of 2026 Democratic voters said their vote was against Trump and not in favor of the party's platform. Half of those who moved from Trump to the Democrats (50%) still hold a favorable view of the Republican Party, which makes them recoverable. Among those who strongly disapprove of the president, Democrats won 90% to 6%. And only 30% of registered voters believe the Democratic Party already has a candidate ready to be president in 2028.

On the source of the anger, the report leaves no room for doubt: 33% of those who voted in 2026 picked the cost of living — including gasoline prices — or the economy as their top issue, and no other issue went above 9%. James Johnson, founding director of J.L. Partners, summed up the reading for Republicans in two sentences: "Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House" and "the GOP should not throw the MAGA baby out with the bathwater just yet." Carson Bradley, the report's author, put it from the other side: "The Democrats got their voters to the polls this year."

Lesson for consultants

This report is an uncomfortable reminder for anyone designing campaigns: persuasion is expensive and mobilization is cheap, but the costliest mistake is confusing the two when reading a result. If two thirds of a 15-point swing is explained by who stayed home, then the strategic question for 2028 is not "whom do we persuade?" but "which of our own no longer thinks it is worth going?" For the Republican consultant the diagnosis is operational: the voter who did not show up is not a lost voter, he is a voter without a reason, and 46% abstention among non-college Republicans says the missing reason is economic, not ideological. For the Democratic consultant the warning is symmetrical: a vote that 48% of their own describe as "against Trump" rather than "for the party" is a borrowed vote, and in 2028 Trump will not be on the ballot. The figure that closes the pincer is the 30% who believe the Democrats already have a presidential-ready candidate: the coalition that won in November still has no one to inherit it.

Source: J.L. Partners · Nov 17, 2026Read the original story ↗

Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.

FOCUS · PDF edition

The print edition, in your inbox

Download the full magazine as a PDF (letter size) and get The Lens every Monday: five takeaways for people who run campaigns.

FOCUS No. 01