The comptroller got 200,000 more votes than the governor while spending 40 times less
Two weeks after November 3, New York is still counting, but the picture is readable. Some 6,132,727 ballots were cast, 45.2% of eligible voters: the highest midterm turnout since 2018. Kathy Hochul won the governorship with 59.9%, nearly twenty points over Bruce Blakeman. Attorney General Letitia James took 60.3%. And Comptroller Tom DiNapoli, the least known of the three, took 64.7%: about 200,000 more votes than the governor, in 13 more counties than her, against a rival who spent roughly $500,000.

Start with turnout, because it orders everything else. The 6,132,727 votes amount to 45.2% of eligible New Yorkers, above the 42.5% of 2022 and half a point below the 45.7% of 2018, the highest midterm figure this century. The average hides the usual gap: Hamilton County, rural and tiny, approached two-thirds turnout, while the Bronx stopped at 31%. Thirty-four points separate the county that votes most from the one that votes least within the same state and under the same rules.
The craft finding is down the ballot. DiNapoli, comptroller since 2007, finished 4.8 points above Hochul and 4.4 above James, and led the vote in 13 more counties than the governor and 10 more than the attorney general. His Republican opponent, Joseph Hernandez, spent around half a million dollars: five times less than James's rival and forty times less than Hochul's. Put the other way, the campaign that faced the most money got the worst of the three results, and the one that faced practically no campaign got the best. New York Focus's tracking also records that much of DiNapoli's advantage over the governor comes from upstate, where voters who rejected Hochul still marked his name.
Three things remain pending. The first is Westchester: none of its 906 election districts had fully reported, with more than 350,000 ballots counted and local turnout above 50%. The second is the 21st congressional district, where Republican Anthony Constantino narrowly beat Democrat Blake Gendebien: Constantino won the Mohawk Valley by nearly twenty points, Gendebien won the North Country by nearly ten and the northern Capital District split roughly down the middle. The third is the 43rd state Senate district, where Democrat Devin Lander leads Republican Jake Ashby by 336 votes, 50.1% to 49.8%; in New York, any margin of 0.5% or less triggers an automatic recount. If Lander holds, Democrats will reach three-quarters of the state Senate.
The calendar sets the limit. Counties must submit certified results by November 28 and the state must certify by December 15. The Associated Press has already called every legislative contest but three, and only one is within recount range. That is: the overall result is not in dispute; what remains open is the fine arithmetic of a legislature that has already changed size.
The DiNapoli case is the best available argument against the idea that money buys votes down the ballot. A comptroller of nineteen years, with no media presence comparable to a governor's or a nationally known attorney general's, beat both in percentage, in raw votes and in counties won, while his opponent spent a fortieth of what Hochul's opponent spent. The explanation is not that money does not work: it is that in low-salience offices the rival's money is also the incumbent's advertising, because it forces voters to form an opinion about someone they had none about. When nobody attacks you, the voter who reaches the third line of the ballot marks the name they recognize. For a consultant the practical implication is twofold: if you advise the challenger for a technical office, your budget should not be spent on your own name recognition but on giving voters a concrete reason to punish the incumbent; and if you advise the top of the ticket, do not mistake the comptroller's strong result for party strength, because 4.8 points between two candidates of the same color on the same ballot are 4.8 points of voters who already took the trouble to tell them apart.
Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.
FOCUS courtesy space
Strategic communication · Political marketingWe bring solutions. We're ready if you are.Strategic analysis, planning, advertising campaigns, art direction and creative sprints for candidates, parties and brands. Polanco, Mexico City.elemental.land →

