Pew: 80% say press criticism keeps politicians in check
Eight in ten U.S. adults say press criticism keeps political leaders from doing things they shouldn’t; 16% say it keeps them from doing their job. It was 75% in September 2025. Among Republicans it rose from 67% in 2024 to 73% today, with a Republican in the White House — breaking the historical pattern.

The Pew Research Center published on November 2 a reading worth keeping at hand before designing any strategy of confrontation with the press. With fieldwork from August 24 to 30, 2026, among 5,166 adults on the American Trends Panel — its probability-based panel — 80% of Americans say criticism from news organizations keeps political leaders from doing things they shouldn’t do, against 16% who say that criticism keeps them from doing their job. In September 2025 the first figure was 75%: five points up in less than a year.
The partisan breakdown is the central finding. Among Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, 89% back that watchdog role, against 81% in 2024. Among Republicans and Republican leaners, 73%, against 67% in that same 2024. Pew underlines why this stands out: historically, appreciation for the press’s critical role moves with who holds the presidency — supporters of the incumbent party value it less — and the Republican move from 2024 to 2026 does not follow that pattern, because it happens with a sitting Republican president. The center adds that within each party, answers do not vary meaningfully by age or ideological position.
There is a second datum in the same series: trust in information from national and local news organizations rose slightly since 2025 in both parties. Pew describes it as a reversal after years of decline, particularly marked among Republicans. It is neither a spectacular recovery nor a change in the absolute level of accumulated distrust, but it breaks a decade-long trend, and it does so in a midterm year where the cost of living and accountability dominated the conversation.
The implication for political communication is uncomfortable for a tactic widely used across the Americas. Attacking the press as an illegitimate actor works to consolidate a base, but this figure says the opposite frame — the press as watchdog — today enjoys a cross-cutting 80% consensus, including nearly three-quarters of Republicans. In other words, the audience that finds the frontal attack persuasive is shrinking, not growing. For a Latin American candidate copying the playbook, the practical reading is to separate a complaint against one specific outlet, which remains viable, from delegitimizing journalism as a function, which today collides with a broad majority of their own electorate.
Distinguish between fighting an outlet and fighting journalism. The first can pay off: it is a concrete adversary, with a name, and it lets you contest one piece of coverage. The second collides with an 80% consensus that includes 73% of Republicans — and it is rising. Before building a strategy of confrontation with the press, measure in your own country how much of your base buys the watchdog frame: if the number looks like the American one, the generic attack costs you more than it gains.
Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.
FOCUS courtesy space
RealClearPollingPolling averagesEvery poll. One average.Follow the U.S. election with RealClearPolling averages.realclearpolling.com →

