Issue No. 01 · November 2026
The magazine of political consulting and marketing
United States · Data

94 to 44: Republican distrust of mail ballots survived the election

Pew Research Center published on November 19 its report on how voters experienced the midterm: 83% of voters say elections were run well across the country and 94% say so about their own community. Underneath those numbers sits a gap that did not close. Among voters who backed the Democratic House candidate, 94% are confident mail ballots nationwide were counted accurately; among those who backed the Republican, 44%. That is a 50-point spread and just three points above the 41% the same group recorded after the 2022 midterm.

94 to 44: Republican distrust of mail ballots survived the election
Photo: Michael Barera / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), an official absentee ballot drop box in Madison, Wisconsin. Crop: FOCUS.

The study comes from the American Trends Panel, Pew's probability-based panel, fielded November 9-15 among 10,247 adults, 7,692 of whom said they voted in the November election. The broad picture is reassuring: 83% of voters rate the administration of elections across the country as very or somewhat well -47% say 'very well'- and the figure rises to 94% when the question is about their own community, with 68% answering 'very well.' The practical experience matches: 79% say voting was very easy and only 4% of in-person voters waited more than half an hour.

Confidence in one's own ballot is also high and, above all, even: 90% of in-person voters and 91% of mail voters are confident their ballot was counted accurately, though only 63% overall are 'very' confident. The problem does not show up when people are asked about themselves, but when they are asked about everyone else. There the measurement splits along party lines, and the deepest cut is in mail voting: 94% of Democratic-candidate voters are confident in the national count of mail and absentee ballots, against 44% of Republican-candidate voters.

The same gap appears, narrower, across the other questions. On whether elections nationwide were run well, 97% of Democratic voters say yes and 63% of Republicans. On confidence that their own vote was counted accurately, 98% against 81%. On the count of in-person votes nationwide, 97% against 76%. In other words: Republican distrust grows the further the question moves from the table where the respondent voted, and peaks in the method their party has spent years questioning.

Pew notes the pattern has a familiar explanation: voters of the losing party tend to express less confidence in the system, and 2026 is no exception. But the number that forces a caveat is the series: after the 2022 midterm, 41% of Republican voters were confident in the national count of mail ballots; today it is 44%. Three points in four years, with two elections in between and one of them won by their party. Distrust of mail voting has stopped moving with the result.

Lesson for consultants

There are two operational lessons here. The first is about proximity: the same person who rates national administration at 63% gives their own community 94%. Electoral trust is built locally, not through national messaging; if you need to defend the legitimacy of a process, your best spokesperson is not the central authority but the neighborhood poll worker. The second is about campaign logistics: when fewer than half of your own voters trust mail voting, you do not have an opinion problem, you have a vote-bank problem. You are giving up the method that lets you lock in ballots weeks before election day, and you are forced to stake everything on a single day, with weather, traffic and lines working against you. Before spending on persuasion, measure what that distrust costs you in actual votes: it is almost always more expensive than fixing it.

Source: Pew Research Center · Nov 19, 2026Read the original story ↗

Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.

FOCUS · PDF edition

The print edition, in your inbox

Download the full magazine as a PDF (letter size) and get The Lens every Monday: five takeaways for people who run campaigns.

FOCUS No. 01