Issue No. 01 · November 2026
The magazine of political consulting and marketing
Global · Messaging

7% for the premier: Victoria's 100 undecided voters give the opposition leader 39%

The four-way debate on the night of Tuesday, November 17, in Melbourne ended with a crushing vote among the 100 undecided voters selected for the News24 and Herald Sun People's Forum: Liberal Jess Wilson took 39%, the Greens' Ellen Sandell 25%, One Nation 16%, and Labor Premier Ben Carroll just 7%, with 13% undecided. Victoria votes on November 28, and Labor, in office since 2014, is fighting for third place against One Nation in every poll this month.

7% for the premier: Victoria's 100 undecided voters give the opposition leader 39%
Photo: DXR / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), Federation Square, Melbourne, Victoria. Cover design: FOCUS.

The format was the worst possible one for a government with 12 years of wear: 100 undecided voters, independently selected, asking live questions for two hours. Australia's ABC, which did not host the event — several leaders had pulled out of debates linked to the public broadcaster — reported the audience's final vote: Jess Wilson 39%, Ellen Sandell 25%, One Nation 16%, and Ben Carroll 7%. Thirteen per cent of the room was still undecided after hearing all four. In other words: the sitting premier convinced 7 out of every 100 people who arrived without a candidate.

The most uncomfortable moment of the night was not about public policy but about proper names. Pressed on the legacy of the Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan governments, Carroll dodged; Wilson dared him to say "Daniel Andrews" out loud and closed with the line that became the headline: "He's not Voldemort." Carroll hit back by asking her to name Jeff Kennett, the Liberal premier of the 1990s, and she did so without hesitation. The ABC described the rest as an exchange of rehearsed lines with little substantive discussion: Wilson calm but with answers that raised more questions — she said her party does not care about the source of electricity as long as it is affordable and reliable, and that she will not change the state's net zero pathway — One Nation candidate Warren Pickering unusually restrained and pressing on exactly that point, and Sandell the surprise of the night.

The numbers Labor brought into the forum explain the 7%. The DemosAU poll for Premier National (October 30 to November 5, 1,562 cases, margin of ±3.4%) put the Coalition at 33%, One Nation at 21%, Labor at 18%, and the Greens at 17%: the governing party, third. Two-party-preferred came out 56-44 for the Coalition, an 11-point swing since the 2022 election. On preferred premier, Wilson 36%, Carroll 28%, Pickering 19%; on net approval, Wilson +13 and Carroll −30. The month's other three readings point to the same place: Lighthouse for the Herald Sun (November 13, 1,351 cases) measured Coalition 32%, One Nation 23%, and Labor 21%; Resolve for The Age (November 2 to 7, 1,000 cases) gave Coalition 30%, One Nation 23%, and Labor 22%; and RedBridge/Accent for the Australian Financial Review (November 3 to 10, 1,008 cases) landed at 57-43 for the Coalition.

The clock does not help. All 88 Legislative Assembly seats are up — 45 for a majority — along with the 40 Legislative Council seats; Labor came in with 54 and would lose its majority with 12 defeats. The Victorian Electoral Commission opened a record 210 early voting centres on November 18, the day after the debate, and voting closes on the 28th. Which means the first impression the forum left is the one hundreds of thousands of people will carry to the ballot box without waiting for election day. And Carroll's central campaign message — "only Labor can stop a Liberal-One Nation government" — just faced its hardest test in front of 100 undecided voters and scored 7 per cent.

Lesson for consultants

Three things this forum puts on the table for any campaign. (1) An undecided-audience format does not measure arguments: it measures permission. A government carrying 12 years does not walk into that room to win, it walks in not to lose, and for that it needs a ten-second answer about its own past. Carroll did not have one, and Wilson's "He's not Voldemort" was precisely the cost of not having it: when a spokesperson cannot say his predecessor's name, the opponent keeps the frame and the audience keeps the scene. Rehearse the proper name that most unsettles your candidate before the other side rehearses it. (2) A defensive message does not produce preference. "Only we can stop X" asks the voter to choose a shield, not a direction; it holds a base, it does not win back undecideds, and 7% is the exact measure of that ceiling. Third place in the polls is fought with your own proposal on the issue people name first — here, cost of living at 41% — not with fear of the third party. (3) Watch the calendar: early voting opened the day after the debate, at 210 centres. When voting starts before the campaign ends, the debate stops being a midpoint milestone and becomes the last free ad; whoever treats it as a dress rehearsal arrives late.

Source: ABC News (Australia) · Nov 17, 2026Read the original story ↗

Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.

FOCUS · PDF edition

The print edition, in your inbox

Download the full magazine as a PDF (letter size) and get The Lens every Monday: five takeaways for people who run campaigns.

FOCUS No. 01