Third place in Victoria: Labor spends its campaign on anti-One Nation ads
Sixteen days out from Australia's November 28 vote, two polls leave Victoria's Labor government on 18% and 22%, behind One Nation. Its answer is a Facebook page with a bar chart and the slogan "Don't Risk It Vic."

The two polls published on November 10 on the election in the Australian state of Victoria, which votes on November 28, agree on the essentials and differ on the magnitude. DemosAU, for the Herald Sun (fieldwork October 30 to November 5, 1,562 cases), has the Coalition on 33%, One Nation 21%, Labor 18% and the Greens 17%. Resolve Strategic, for The Age (November 2 to 7, 1,000 cases), measures Coalition 30%, One Nation 23%, Labor 22% and Greens 13%. In both, the party that has governed Victoria since 2014 runs third. In 2022 Labor won with 37.0% of the primary vote and 55-45 two-party preferred; RedBridge/Accent Research now measures that split at 57-43 for the Coalition.
The Labor campaign's reaction is the craft story. According to Crikey, the party set up a Facebook page called "Don't Risk It Vic" and used it to run ads aimed at Brunswick, an inner-Melbourne seat it is contesting with the Greens. The ad does not attack the Coalition or One Nation with a policy argument: it shows an unlabelled bar chart in which Liberal and One Nation votes reach a majority, and in which adding all Greens support to Labor still falls short. The campaign message, in one line: "only Labor can stop a Liberal-One Nation government."
Kos Samaras, director of RedBridge and a former Labor strategist, explained in the same report why the ad buy is not moving the needle: anti-One Nation messaging works better with Labor's own base than with the voter it wants to take, and the soft One Nation voter, once dislodged, will "probably jump over to the Liberal Party," not to Labor. His reading is that the campaign is already in preservation mode: "they're not trying to get 45 seats." RedBridge estimates Labor could be cut to "somewhere in the 20s" of the lower house's 88 seats. Premier Ben Carroll defends Niddrie on a 6.7% margin, and Mordialloc (8.2%), Point Cook (8.3%) and Clarinda (10.2%) have joined the risk list.
The limit of the fear frame is in the data itself: Resolve found that 48% of Victorians are comfortable with the idea of a coalition including One Nation, and Newspoll measured 28% who would prefer a Liberal-National-One Nation government after the election. When half the electorate does not consider the party your ad presents as a risk unacceptable, the ad stops being a warning and becomes free advertising. The historical references already circulating in Melbourne do not help Labor's mood: New South Wales Labor was left with 20 seats in 2011 and Queensland Labor with seven in 2012.
A note on method: the two polls differ by four points on the Labor vote and four on the Greens, and the report itself flags DemosAU as a possible outlier. The robust conclusion is not the exact number but the order: third place.
Before building a campaign on the risk your opponent poses, measure whether your target electorate finds them unacceptable. If it does not, the negative ad mobilizes your base, raises your rival's profile and pushes the soft voter toward the third option, not toward you.
Summary written by the FOCUS editors based on the original story. Rights to the original content belong to its publisher.
FOCUS courtesy space


